Simulate
Check the first claim with numbers
This review asks for three proofs: one about sets, one about maps and one about sizes. The first is a law that lets you multiply out set expressions, as with numbers.
The cell tries all 512 triples of subsets of . It also tries a careless version, with the second left out.
The law holds for all 512 triples. The careless version, , fails for 296 of them.
Conjecture
The distributive law. For any sets , and ,
Every triple of subsets of one three-element set. The proof must work for any sets.
Format 4
Write it
Prove that for any sets , and , by double inclusion as in lesson PG6.1.
Saved in this browser as you type.
Write your own first: a proof you have tried to write teaches far more than one you only read.
Simulate
Check the second claim
Lesson PG6.2 showed that a chain of injective maps is injective, and that can be injective when is not. What about the inner map ? The cell tries every from a 2-element set to a 3-element set, with every from there to a 3-element set.
In all 243 pairs, is injective whenever is. The outer map need not be: in 72 pairs, is injective but is not.
Conjecture
If and , and is injective, then is injective.
Every pair of maps between three small sets. The proof must work for any sets, and must use only the injectivity of .
Format 4
Write it
Prove that if is injective, then is injective. Start from two inputs of with the same output.
Saved in this browser as you type.
Write your own first: a proof you have tried to write teaches far more than one you only read.
Simulate
Check the third claim
A subset of can be written as a toss sequence: toss is H when and T when . For subsets of the sequences have 4 tosses, and the cell checks that this pairs the subsets off with the sequences.
The 16 subsets give 16 different sequences, all 16 there are: becomes HTHT, and the empty set TTTT. A set of elements has subsets, far more than : 1,048,576 for .
Conjecture
The set of all subsets of is uncountable.
Finite sets only. For itself, the proof combines this pairing with lesson PG6.4.
Format 4
Write it
Prove that the subsets of cannot be listed. Use lesson PG6.4, and the map that sends a subset to the toss sequence with H at place exactly when .
Saved in this browser as you type.
Write your own first: a proof you have tried to write teaches far more than one you only read.
The diagonal idea goes further. For any set , no map from onto its set of subsets exists: this is Cantor's theorem, proved in the further reading. So there is no largest infinite size.
Summary card
- To prove two sets equal, prove each is a subset of the other, splitting into cases where an "or" appears.
- If is injective, then is injective; need not be.
- A map onto a set carries a list of its inputs to a list of its outputs. So if the outputs cannot be listed, neither can the inputs.
- The subsets of match the infinite toss sequences, so they are uncountable.